The 7 best Italian restaurants in Reno, according to Reddit

If you’re on the hunt for the best Italian restaurants in Reno, Reddit users have got you covered. Known for its rich flavors, Italian cuisine has long been a favorite among food enthusiasts. Whether you’re craving a classic pasta dish or something more innovative, Reno Italian restaurants offer a wide variety of options that are sure to delight your palate. We’ve scoured Reddit threads to bring you a list of the top Italian dining spots in Reno that you absolutely must try.

Johnny’s Ristorante

For those seeking an authentic Italian dining experience, Johnny’s Ristorante stands out with its classic recipes and cozy ambiance. Reddit users rave about their homemade pasta and delectable sauces, which are the cornerstone of the menu. The inviting atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for both family gatherings and romantic dinners. From their rich lasagna to the savory osso buco, Johnny’s Ristorante provides a genuine taste of Italy right in Reno.

La Famiglia

La Famiglia is a treasured establishment in Reno, offering a warm, family-owned atmosphere where traditional Italian recipes are lovingly prepared. Reddit users frequently highlight the exceptional quality of their dishes, which are rooted in age-old family traditions. The menu features a variety of standout options, such as veal saltimbocca and homemade gnocchi, each crafted with a meticulous attention to detail.

Diners appreciate the authentic flavors and the care put into each meal, making La Famiglia a must-visit spot for anyone craving a genuine Italian dining experience. The welcoming ambiance and friendly service further enhance the experience, ensuring that every visit feels like a special occasion.

Pasta Fresca

Pasta Fresca has quickly become a favorite among Reno Italian restaurants due to its unwavering commitment to freshness and quality. The restaurant’s menu is a celebration of fresh pasta, which is made daily to ensure the best possible flavor and texture. Reddit users are particularly fond of their inventive approach to traditional Italian dishes. 

One standout menu item is the lobster ravioli, praised for its rich, buttery filling and delicate pasta shell. Another must-try is the truffle risotto, which combines earthy truffles with creamy risotto for a truly indulgent dish. The menu also offers a variety of seasonal specials that highlight local and fresh ingredients, ensuring that there’s always something new to try. 

Pasta Fresca’s ambiance complements its culinary offerings, providing a warm and inviting setting perfect for any occasion. Whether you’re dining solo or with a group, the restaurant’s attentive service and thoughtfully curated wine list add to the overall dining experience. Redditors consistently recommend Pasta Fresca for anyone looking to enjoy high-quality Italian cuisine with a modern twist.

Casale’s Halfway Club

Casale’s Halfway Club offers a dining experience steeped in history, making it a beloved spot for both locals and visitors. Established in the early 20th century, this restaurant has maintained its old-world charm while continuously serving up delicious Italian dishes. Reddit users frequently mention the unique ambiance that comes with dining at Casale’s, where the walls tell stories of generations past.

The menu here is a tribute to hearty Italian fare with generous portions that ensure no one leaves hungry. Standout dishes include the famed fried ravioli, which is crispy on the outside and bursting with flavor on the inside, and their legendary minestrone soup, a comforting bowl of rich, hearty goodness. The house-made sausages and the lasagna are also highly recommended by frequent diners. 

La Cucina

La Cucina is a haven for those who appreciate a modern take on traditional Italian cuisine. The restaurant’s sleek, contemporary design creates an inviting atmosphere that complements its inventive menu. Reddit users are particularly fond of the artful presentation and robust flavors featured in dishes like the porcini mushroom risotto, which boasts earthy notes and a creamy texture, and the duck ragu pappardelle, a hearty dish that perfectly marries rich duck meat with wide, tender noodles.

One of the standout features of La Cucina is its ability to blend the old with the new. The menu offers a variety of options that range from traditional favorites to more adventurous creations, ensuring there’s something for every palate. Redditors frequently mention the exceptional quality of the ingredients used, which is evident in every bite. For those who enjoy seafood, the restaurant offers a deliciously fresh octopus carpaccio that is both light and flavorful.

Mario’s Portofino

If you’re a fan of seafood, Mario’s Portofino is a must-visit among Reno Italian restaurants. Reddit users frequently praise the restaurant’s ability to seamlessly blend traditional Italian flavors with the freshest ocean ingredients. Their seafood linguine, packed with a medley of shrimp, clams, and mussels in a savory tomato sauce, is a particular favorite. The grilled calamari, tender and perfectly seasoned, also garners high marks from diners.

Beyond seafood, Mario’s Portofino offers a range of classic Italian dishes such as rich, velvety fettuccine Alfredo and a robust eggplant Parmesan. The restaurant’s versatile menu ensures there’s something for everyone, making it a top choice for varied palates. Additionally, the cozy yet elegant ambiance of Mario’s Portofino adds to its charm, providing a delightful dining experience that captures the essence of Italian hospitality.

Zozo’s Ristorante

Zozo’s Ristorante is a gem among Reno Italian restaurants, known for its warm, inviting atmosphere and expertly crafted dishes. Reddit users often highlight the restaurant’s intimate setting, which makes it an ideal choice for a relaxed and enjoyable meal. Zozo’s menu features a harmonious blend of comforting Italian classics and sophisticated dishes, ensuring there’s something to satisfy every craving.

One standout dish that Redditors frequently mention is the chicken marsala, a rich and savory entrée that perfectly balances tender chicken with a flavorful marsala wine sauce. Another favorite is the creamy tortellini Alfredo, which combines delicate pasta filled with cheese and a sumptuous Alfredo sauce for a truly indulgent experience. 

The attention to detail at Zozo’s extends beyond the main courses. The appetizers, such as bruschetta topped with fresh tomatoes and basil, set the stage for a delightful meal. Additionally, their tiramisu, a beloved Italian dessert, is often praised for its light, creamy texture and perfectly balanced coffee flavor.

Zozo’s Ristorante’s dedication to flavor, hospitality, and ambiance has earned it a loyal following, making it a cherished destination for anyone seeking an authentic and memorable Italian dining experience in Reno.

READ MORE: The top 10 sandwich spots in Reno

This story was generated in part by AI and edited by The Nevadan staff.